Expected behavior
As an overview-broker user deployed in cloudfoundry
- in order to support application restarts while still serving incoming OSB requests
- I need that offering/plans guid to not change across application restarts
Observed behavior
Following e11bba2 the uuids are randomly generated at application restart.
Consequently, if the overview broker was registered in cloudfoundry the following errors will be observed
- service instance provisionning requests fail with message
Could not find service 895749e2-8543-4f9d-8134-3a71b4a388c4, plan 8fb7951a-f309-496a-89b2-7cbdec5a3dcc
- if there are existing service instances, errors will occur while trying to deprovision them with message
Could not find service 895749e2-8543-4f9d-8134-3a71b4a388c4, plan 8fb7951a-f309-496a-89b2-7cbdec5a3dcc
- if the broker registration in cloudfoundry is requested, then it fails with the following message, because the services are already registered with a same name but distinct ids
Server error, status code: 502, error code: 270012, message: Service broker catalog is invalid:
Service names must be unique within a broker. Services with names ["overview-service"] already exist
Workaround
Systematically perform a cf purge-service-offering -f overview-service -b overview-broker prior to execute a cf update-service-broker
Suggested fix
- Use consistent hash (e.g. md5) from names (respectively service name and service plan name) as Guids
- Add an opt-in (e.g.
OSB_GUID_OFFSET) which adds an offset to the consistent hash, enabling registration of multiple overview broker instances in K8S svcat (CF support multi service registration out of the box)
Expected behavior
As an overview-broker user deployed in cloudfoundry
Observed behavior
Following e11bba2 the uuids are randomly generated at application restart.
Consequently, if the overview broker was registered in cloudfoundry the following errors will be observed
Could not find service 895749e2-8543-4f9d-8134-3a71b4a388c4, plan 8fb7951a-f309-496a-89b2-7cbdec5a3dccCould not find service 895749e2-8543-4f9d-8134-3a71b4a388c4, plan 8fb7951a-f309-496a-89b2-7cbdec5a3dccWorkaround
Systematically perform a
cf purge-service-offering -f overview-service -b overview-brokerprior to execute acf update-service-brokerSuggested fix
OSB_GUID_OFFSET) which adds an offset to the consistent hash, enabling registration of multiple overview broker instances in K8S svcat (CF support multi service registration out of the box)